New study shows Europe’s fiscal winners and losers from EU immigration
22 March 2018
A large majority of European Economic Area (EEA) countries saw net fiscal benefits from EU immigration (people born in one EU country and living in another) between 2004 and 2015, the first major cross national analysis has shown.
However the analysis – undertaken by researchers at Sweden’s University of Uppsala, as part of a larger Oxford University project – also shows that the benefits were distributed unevenly. The findings create opportunities for policy-makers around Europe to compare approaches and outcomes, and potentially to refine and improve both national and EU-wide policies.
Switzerland, Cyprus, Norway and Belgium experienced the greatest net fiscal benefits, while Slovakia, Poland and Estonia experienced the greatest net fiscal cost of EU immigration. In all, more than two thirds of EEA countries saw net fiscal gains from EU immigration.
The findings come from the first major pan-EEA analysis of the fiscal impacts of European mobility. The research was undertaken by researchers at the University of Uppsala in Sweden, as part of the REMINDER (Role of European Mobility and its Impacts in Narratives, Debates and EU Reforms) Project – a major international programme of research run by the University of Oxford and funded by Horizon 2020, which is investigating the social and economic impacts of freedom of movement around the EU, and public discourse about the issue.
The vast majority of EEA countries – 21 out of 29 – saw positive net fiscal impacts during 2004-2015, receiving more in taxes and other contributions from EU migrants than they then spent in services (such as education, healthcare, infrastructure costs, welfare benefits and other costs) that were provided to EU migrants.
Report co-author Dr Rafael Ahlskog, a researcher at the University of Uppsala said: “Our analysis shows that in most countries in the EEA, EU citizens pay slightly more in taxes and other contributions to the state than they receive in services, meaning that they make a net fiscal contribution. This isn’t the case in all EEA countries, and a few – generally lower-income countries in Eastern Europe – end up with fiscal losses. The countries that have tended to see the biggest net benefits are countries that have a significant share of EU migrants in their populations.”
However, in almost all countries – whether the net fiscal impact was positive or negative – it represented a relatively small fraction of GDP – less than +/-0.4% in 24 out of 29 cases.
Dr Pär Nyman, co-author of the report and a researcher at the University of Uppsala, said: “The analysis is important because it provides a bigger picture allowing us to scrutinise the impacts of a common policy. It shows that in most cases – whether the effect is positive or negative – it is relatively limited and generally accounts for less than 0.4% of GDP. Nevertheless, this can still mean many billions in revenue – or, less commonly, costs – for a nation’s economy.
Dr Nyman added: “It is important to keep in mind, however, that these figures are all calculated based on a number of necessary assumptions, and should be taken as fairly robust pointers rather than the absolute truth.”
The analysis is consistent with other independent cross-national analyses of the fiscal impacts of immigration – notably work undertaken by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), though this did not look specifically at EU mobility. It also highlights the need for improved processes for collecting and comparing social and economic data from across the European Union.
Dr Carlos Vargas-Silva, Head of the REMINDER Project at the University of Oxford said: “The researchers have produced the first ever cross national analysis of the fiscal impacts of EU immigration. It shows clearly that the majority of EEA member states saw fiscal benefits, but was made considerably more difficult by the different ways that migration data is collected around the bloc. Hopefully greater efforts can be made at consistency in the future, which will allow better understanding of the impacts of migration.”
Peace is best established with respect for local traditions and women’s needs
30 januari 2019
Lasting peace is best created with consideration for local conflict resolution traditions and with great sensitivity for the grassroots perspective, and above all, for the needs of female victims.
Is it possible to predict the labour market of the future?
15 januari 2019
Oskar Nordström Skans, Professor of Economics, has received funding from the Swedish Research Council to develop the research environment “Technological development and the future labour market”.
The Torgny Segerstedt Medal to Peter Wallensteen
06 december 2018
This year the Torgny Segerstedt Medal goes to Peter Wallensteen, a post-retirement professor at Uppsala University. He receives it for his extensive contributions to peace and conflict research.
Industrial robots increase wages for employees
22 oktober 2018
In addition to increasing productivity, the introduction of industrial robots has increased wages for the employees. At the same time, industrial robots have also changed the labour market by increasing the number of job opportunities for highly s...
Populism boosted by economism
12 september 2018
The rise of a populist party like the Sweden Democrats in Sweden is usually said to be linked to the past few years’ refugee flows. But the explanation lies deeper than that: in how the welfare systems function in today’s Sweden, says Sten Widmalm...
“In an uncertain political situation, the PM should resign”
12 september 2018
Not all the votes in the Swedish election have been counted, and the political situation is unclear. We talked to Li Bennich-Björkman, Professor of Political Science at Uppsala University, to hear what is going on.
Food in elderly care better with dieticians
21 augusti 2018
While both the Swedish National Food Agency and the Swedish National Board of Health and Welfare in recent years have come up with new guidelines for food for the elderly, not all municipalities conform to them by any means. There are different co...
Working memory might be more flexible than previously thought
16 augusti 2018
Breaking with the long-held idea that working memory has fixed limits, a new study by researchers at Uppsala University and New York University suggests that these limits adapt themselves to the task that one is performing. The results are present...
Fatalities in organised violence still decreasing
18 juni 2018
New data from the Uppsala Conflict Data Program (UCDP), Uppsala University shows that the number of fatalities in organised violence decreased for the third consecutive year. In 2017, almost 90,000 deaths were recorded by UCDP, a decrease of 32% c...
First forecasts from ViEWS – the Violence Early-Warning System
08 juni 2018
The challenges of preventing, mitigating, and adapting to large-scale political violence are daunting, particularly when violence escalates where it is not expected. With funding from the ERC, Uppsala researchers have developed ViEWS: a political ...
New doctoral thesis: How over-production of meat is maintained
07 juni 2018
Meat consumption is high in Sweden, but production nevertheless outstrips demand. In a new doctoral thesis in sociology, Jonas Bååth has studied how Swedish meat producers are handling the problems that arise when supply of their products exceeds ...
Shamus Khan awarded the 2018 Hans L. Zetterberg Prize
05 juni 2018
Professor Shamus Khan of Columbia University is the second recipient of the Hans L. Zetterberg Prize in Sociology. The prize sum is SEK 100,000.
This year’s Distinguished Teaching Award winners chosen
04 juni 2018
The 2018 Distinguished Teaching Award winners at Uppsala University teach subjects related to art history, informatics and media, pharmaceutical biosciences and information technology. The free Distinguished Teaching Award was presented to Senior ...
First open system providing warning of conflicts
04 juni 2018
Hello, there Håvard Hegre, Dag Hammarskjöld Professor in the Department of Peace and Conflict Research. An initial version of the analytical tool called ViEWS (a political Violence Early-Warning System) was unveiled in June. What is it?
Shared meals important for wellbeing
29 maj 2018
How, where and when we eat are key issues for human health and wellbeing. A multidisciplinary research network at Uppsala University aims to deepen knowledge about the significance of meals.
Premier of research documentary on alternative entrepreneurship
14 maj 2018
An ethnographic research documentary on alternative entrepreneurship in Hungary will premier on the 16th of May. We talked to researchers Annika Skoglund and David Redmalm, members of the research group that created the documentary Pride - Alterna...
Is citizenship necessary for being part of a democracy?
26 april 2018
Nowadays, civil rights are usually connected with citizenship of a country. But how do growing globalisation and more mobility affect this?
Mobilising for research on higher education
26 april 2018
Remarkably little research is conducted on higher education in Sweden, but a large share of existing research on the subject is at Uppsala University. Through a research network for research on higher education, researchers are now mobilising to d...
Most EEA countries benefit financially from EU mobility
28 mars 2018
In a new report, Uppsala University researchers show that most countries in the European Economic Area (EEA) benefit financially when they receive a citizen from an EU country who moves there to live and work. The report includes migration between...
Sustainable peace is more than lack of violence
28 mars 2018
In a world of conflict and violence new knowledge on how to build sustainable peace is urgently needed. In his dissertation, PhD candidate Florian Krampe emphasizes the need for helping countries to reset their internal relations on a peaceful path.